Which Research Firms Adjust the Accounting to Value Stocks?
Valens Research does, and FA Alpha publishes its work for financial advisors. Valens applies more than 130 adjustments to the reported statements of over 25,000 companies under a standard it calls Uniform Accounting. UBS HOLT, New Constructs, and ISS EVA each have a framework of their own.
Each of these research firms uses a proprietary accounting-adjustment framework to value stocks. All of them start from the belief that the reported statements need adjusting before a ratio means much. They differ in what they adjust, what they measure, and who they serve.
What Does Valens Research Adjust Before Valuing a Stock?
Valens Research describes itself as “a global investment services firm with research powered by the proprietary UAFRS framework.” It applies “over 130 individual adjustments” to the financial statements of more than 25,000 companies. FA Alpha publishes that research for financial advisors. Uniform Accounting, Valens’ name for UAFRS, adjusts the reported statements so every company is on one comparable basis. FA Alpha’s forensic accounting article explains how.
The adjustments cover R&D, operating leases, stock options, excess cash, and goodwill, among others, and the full category list is public at uafrs.org/adjustments. Once every company’s statements are on one basis, Valens calculates a Uniform return on assets and a Uniform P/E. Its Embedded Expectations Analysis then starts from the stock price and calculates what the market expects from the company’s future cash flows.
On September 22, 2022, Altimetry, the consumer arm of Valens Research, published both sets of figures for Deere. Deere’s as-reported return on assets was 4% in 2020 and 6% in 2021. Its Uniform return on assets was 21% and 15% in those same years.
The as-reported numbers say the return rose from 2020 to 2021. The Uniform numbers say it fell, and the two disagree on the level in both years. If you think audited GAAP numbers are close enough for comparing companies, Deere’s two readings say otherwise. FA Alpha explains the mechanics in why GAAP earnings can distort profitability.
Which Other Firms Have Their Own Framework?
UBS calls HOLT “a corporate performance and valuation service of UBS.” Its “proprietary methodology corrects subjectivity in corporate financial statements by converting income statement and balance sheet information into a CFROI return.” CFROI stands for cash flow return on investment. HOLT’s database covers over 20,000 companies, and UBS says it’s “used by asset managers around the world” and by “professional investors, including equity analysts, hedge funds, quantitative analysts, and activist investors.”
New Constructs calls itself “an independent research technology firm.” Its measure is ROIC, return on invested capital. The firm’s ROIC page says, “When we calculate ROIC, we make numerous adjustments to close accounting loopholes and ensure apples-to-apples comparability across thousands of companies.” The data comes “especially from the footnotes and MD&A.” New Constructs says its clients range “from quant funds” to “PMs, advisors and individuals.”
ISS EVA, from ISS STOXX, says, “We use underlying economic profit to measure and analyze the corporate performance of 28,000 companies globally.” EVA stands for economic value added. Fidelity’s page on the firm says EVA “measures profit only after deducting the full cost of capital,” that “research is treated as valuable capital,” and that “leased assets are treated as if owned.”
What Should an Advisor Ask About an Accounting Framework?
Before you compare research platforms for your practice, put three questions to any of these frameworks.
- What does it adjust, and is the category list public?
- Is every company adjusted the same way, so two companies can be compared?
- Who was it built for?
Key points
- Valens Research applies more than 130 adjustments to over 25,000 companies under Uniform Accounting.
- Deere’s as-reported ROA rose from 4% to 6% in 2020 and 2021, while its Uniform ROA fell from 21% to 15%.
- UBS HOLT measures CFROI, New Constructs ROIC, and ISS EVA economic profit across 28,000 companies.
- Ask any framework what it adjusts, whether every company gets the same treatment, and who it serves.
Uniform Accounting at work, every morning
FA Alpha Daily puts Uniform Accounting to work on a company, a metric, or a market signal, free for financial advisors.
